Posting here without the endorsement of Wired News. In no way do I or can I speak for anyone at Wired News. It’s just me. And I’m pissed.
Thanks, Philip Chien, subject of:
Wired News: Wired News Writer Faked Info
Do you have any idea how hard writers like me work to find quality sources? Do you have any idea how careful I am to build rapport and let my sources know they can trust me?
Every person I have ever interviewed, quoted, mentioned or otherwise alluded to in my published work has one thing in common: they exist. (I specify “published” because I have some stories and novel manuscripts that have made-up people because, um, they’re fiction, but they’re not published either. Yet.)
My job, as wonderful as it is, is not easy. If it looks easy to you it’s because I do a damn good job of making it look like I just sat down and jotted off something all la-la breezy. That’s called voice, by the way. I strive for conversational, funny, honest, personal, analytical. But it’s always true. And the people I talk to are always real.
That people like you, and Michelle Delio before you, would undermine and profane the efforts that other Wired News writers like me make … I’m sputtering. It’s vile. It tarnishes the whole publication, the whole profession.
And it’s so unnecessary!
One of your sources is dead, but supposedly he really said what you quoted. Fine. Tell us that. “‘blah blah,’ Collins said in 1995, two years before his death.” Connect him to the present day — was he unusually prescient? Was he wrong? Did he get proven right after being misunderstood in his lifetime?
But to make up quotes from someone you never talked with? I know it takes work but it’s not impossible to find a good source — a great one — to give you real quotes and information for your real story. The story might not turn out to be what you thought it would be, but that’s just fine. You tell the story you find, not the story you wrapped up neatly over the weekend and just wanted some expert lines tucked into to make it sound legit.
If Robert Ash didn’t want to talk to you, fine. You could have found another space historian or aeronautical engineer. As for your excuse that Ash was upset with you and had cut off communications, well, do you have notes or a recording of the interviews that you claim took place that Ash claims did not? A sticky note with his number and a date and time to call? Any suggestion at all that he is lying when he says he never spoke with you?
I think you should have to donate to a media literacy education program whatever you made from your Wired News stories, times ten.